Utah’s Death Penalty doesn’t make us any Safer.

It’s time to repeal and replace the Death Penalty.

Make your voice heard. Email your Legislator today.

It’s time that we have a conversation in this state about the death penalty. It has shown that it does not protect or punish more than a sentence of life in prison without parole. Yet its cost to the taxpayer and victims’ families is so much more.

Utah County recently spent nearly 4 million dollars seeking the death penalty in a case that had nothing to do with any Utah County Resident. Its only ties were that the alleged crime was committed about 1 mile inside our border.’Had he committed the alleged crime a mile away in another county, that county would have had to pay the huge sum in order to seek the death penalty.

They most likely would not have sought the death penalty because of the cost.

The punishment for crime should be the same wherever you commit it in this state. Life without parole is a death sentence and keeps killers off the streets. It costs less, does not re-victimize the families or celebritize the offender.

Join us by being a part of this conversation with our legislators.

Bill Lee

Utah County Commission, Chair

The Death Penalty is the BIG LIE.

It’s the lie we tell victims and concerned citizens, knowing full well that the death sentence will never be carried out. Our victim family members deserve justice, not the false promise of justice that will never be served. It’s the lie used by politicians and prosecutors to get and to stay elected.

Murder deserves a swift response. However, the death penalty system is never swift. It’s become bloated and broken. Due process provides the accused resources and multiple appeals in an effort to assure innocents are not executed. Unfortunately, the government got it wrong in 1 of 10 death sentences. Ten percent of those receiving the death penalty were found innocent.

Utah residents: as conservatives, as liberals, as moderates, we can limit the power of government to take a life. Support the effort repeal and replace Utah’s Death Penalty adding an additional punishment to life in prison without parole and 25+ to life. Contact your legislators and let them know Utah supports repealing Utah’s Death Penalty and replacing it by adding a new 45+to life sentence.

The conservative approach to crime is to end the death penalty. The death penalty is the BIG LIE. It costs taxpayers millions—much more than life in prison without parole.

The truth is it requires millions and millions of dollars to litigate a death penalty case.

Taxpayers pay for the defense, the prosecution, all of the experts, the decades of appeals in a trial that is distinctly different because it seeks death. Yet data shows it doesn’t make us any safer.

Life without parole is better. It keeps a dangerous killer in prison and doesn’t waste taxpayer dollars.

See the data and learn more. Then make your voice heard. Email your legislator TODAY.

Amelia Powers Gardner

Utah County Commissioner

The death penalty falsely promotes an illusion of safety. It also increases our collective anger and diminishes what we can and should be doing for each and every victim of crime.

The death penalty is The Big Lie. It’s the lie we tell victims and concerned citizens, knowing full well that the death sentence will never be carried out. Our victim family members deserve justice, not the false promise of justice that will never be served. It’s the lie used by politicians and prosecutors to get and to stay elected.

I’m not that kind of prosecutor. I’m not that kind of politician. I’m not that kind of person. I’m not here to stay elected. I’m here to do the job you elected me to do—and that is to wisely use the resources you provide through your taxes in the most effective way to help more victims and to protect the community. Continuing to seek the Death Penalty perpetuates a criminal justice system that is not only broken but based on entirely false concepts of justice and safety.

That’s how I’m doing it in Utah County; that’s what we need to do across our entire state. Contact your Legislator. Urge them to repeal the death penalty.

David O. Leavitt

Utah County Attorney

Learn More About the Death Penalty

According to Pew Research and the Death Penalty Information Center, support for the Death Penalty continues a significant decline in support and executions.

Dive deeper into the issue…

Conservative Approach

Should government have the power to execute? Statistics show that government gets it wrong 1 out of 10 times. That means 10% sentenced to death are ultimately found innocent. That also means the real killer remains free. Conservatives should lead the effort to repeal and replace Utah’s death penalty. Government should not have that much power.

Sentencing Options

Adding an additional option 45+ to life provides another prosecutorial tool. Rep. Lowry Snow and Sen. Dan McKay will sponsor legislation that adds one additional harsher punishment under Utah law and removes the Death Penalty. We believe that this tool will provide all we need as a community to maintain safety and seek swifter punishment.

Death Penalty Process

Because we have given the government the power to take a life, the trial and appeals process is far more complex than other trials. Taxpayers pay the defense, the prosecution, court costs, appeals, a two-phase trial, and other costs. In Utah, we have not had an execution in over 11 years. Nationwide the average execution takes 22 years.

Weighing the Costs

In Utah County we try nearly 6000 cases annually of a wide variety of crim. Our budgets are set, except when a death penalty case becomes part of that mix. Our county has spent upwards of $4 million to try a current case. That includes costs for prosecution, defense and experts. We were not even to trial. Additionally troubling is resources pulled away from 18 other murders and 150+ sexual assault cases that deserve attention, focus, and resolution for those victims.

Additionally, Utah spent  $40 million pursuing 160 death penalty cases over the previous two decades with two cases resulting in a death sentence.

Crime Deterrence

Many argue that the death penalty is a deterrent, a bargaining chip, or necessary to drive an outcome. Data shows that murders are lower in states without the death penalty. Using death as a bargaining chip, gives the government power to extract an outcome without having to prove the accusations it makes. That takes away important constitutional protections designed to preserve and protect the liberties given in the Constitution. Do we want government to have that kind of power over its citizens? Look at the data and consider our liberties and if the Death Penalty truly serves that end.

Justice for All Victims

Justice is often associated with punishment under the law. It focuses on retribution. Justice also includes the principle of moral rightness, treating all members of society with regard, including the equitable use of resources. As our office seeks to meet the needs of all victims, the safety of the community must also be considered. Life in prison is far more effective. Making a killer a celebrity in the news through a drawn-out appeals process, delaying punishment, absorbing limited resources needed for other cases, and delivering no difference in a drawn-out, expensive effort to chase after retribution as the only just outcome.